In mid-January, research house SuperRatings said that members could expect ‘solid’ returns in 2020. While 2019 had been a bumper year, powered by one of the best equities markets’ run since 2013, the outlook for the year ahead was still optimistic albeit with a slightly lower 12 month return forecasted.
SuperRatings, like the rest of market participants, could never have foreseen the devastation that would result from COVID-19. Fast forward just one month and the equities markets tumbled by a reported 36% between February 20th and March 23rd. Optimism was no longer the mood of the day.
Australian investors have a strong predilection for shares, particularly Australian shares, exasperated by a consistently low interest rate environment this century. After a decade of mostly rising share prices and falling interest rates, many investors were increasingly over-confident that shares would continue to provide both capital appreciation and income via dividends.
Then the dividend tide turned.
There has been a dividend boom over the last ten years and the tide has now turned. UBS calculated that investors had enjoyed a dividend payout of $80 billion last year alone. Now Plato Investment Management is suggesting that investors will take a $26 billion hit this year as Australia’s largest companies axe or defer their dividend payments to investors.
This has come as a shock to many. Unprecedented is perhaps one of the most overtraded words of 2020 but it is no surprise that so many retail shareholders and institutional investors made an assumption that dividends would continue to be paid by our most prosperous companies, even in turbulent times. Never before have we seen such widespread axing or deferral of dividends.
But COVID-19 has challenged the prosperity of most companies and called into doubt the Australian share dividend gravy train. With the exception of toilet paper companies, some technology providers and PPE suppliers, few companies have escaped COVID-19 without taking some kind of hit.
In early April, the Reserve Bank of New Zealand announced Australia's big four banks’ operations in New Zealand should stop paying dividends back to their parent banks in Australia as a proactive move to protect the New Zealand economy from the crisis. Consequently, after APRA’s announcement with regards to capital requirements, Bank of Queensland was the first to announce that dividends would be deferred here in Australia.
Many of the major Australian corporates followed suit. Last month Westpac broke the news to its 610,000 retail shareholders it would suspend dividends for the first time in 37 years, and insurance giant IAG told its 650,000 shareholders a dividend payment is unlikely to be forthcoming.
This is leading to a recalibration of risk.
SMSFs and retirees will undoubtedly be hurting as their retirement income is negatively impacted this year. The super fund sector is under pressure as a consequence of holding illiquid assets amid demand resulting from the early access super schemes.
Change is afoot.
Part of this change will result in funds reducing their allocation to illiquid unlisted assets and we expect to see more money moving to risk-averse assets such as fixed income, particularly in the investment grade space.
Open an account with FIIG in less than 5 minutes
We are also seeing more opportunities for super funds to take greater advantage of corporate bond investment. Changes to ‘repo’ or repurchasing arrangements means that investment grade bonds can be sold to the RBA on the understanding they are repurchased at a future time and at a pre-arranged price. With recent regulatory change to broaden the classification of repo eligibility, we are expecting to see more investment grade corporate bonds issued (Woolworths is one such example) as the regulator provides a lifeline to markets similar to during the GFC when it supported the RMBS market.
The Government is also issuing record amounts of fixed income and this will create more opportunities for investors looking to reweight their fixed income allocation at the lower risk end of the spectrum. The recent Australian Government $19 billion 10-year bond issue at a yield of 1 per cent shows high levels of investor confidence in lending to the Australian Government for a long period of time at low rates.
There is a feeling of déjà vu.
This recalibration of risk and transition to and within the fixed income sector is something we have witnessed before. In the three-year post GFC period there was a strategic shift to fixed income, according to recent research by SEM Benchmarking. Those top quartile funds that best weathered the storm started with a greater allocation to fixed income (37%) and this was increased in the subsequent three years to 45%. Those who were worst affected by the GFC had a smaller allocation to defensive assets but also increased their allocation from 28% to 30% in the same three-year period. And this was at a time when term deposits were paying 4%. Today investors are struggling to find 2%.
We expect to see a similar trend as a result of the global COVID-19 crisis (GCC) as investors take advantage of fixed income as an alternative performing asset class in this time of volatility. We expect that the lure of coupon payments in the absence of dividends will also prove attractive as they provide certainty in what are very uncertain times.
In praise of fixed income.
For some superannuation funds the expertise is already inhouse and they have the ability to seamlessly reallocate capital across asset classes. Indeed, some of the larger super funds have seen their larger-than-average allocation to fixed income vindicated since the start of the crisis.
In the recent Super Fund of the Year awards, $113 billion QSuper was the winner of the Best Fund in acknowledgement of its success in protecting members in turbulent times like the present, attributed in part to the prominence of defensive assets. The organisers, Chant West, commented that the results recognised QSuper’s ‘smaller allocation to equities and larger allocation to bonds, and it's helped them smooth the volatility of their investment performance in recent times. QSuper's investment model was designed to protect members in times just like this." QSuper and UniSuper were also both revealed as the best-performing growth super funds during the FY18/19 with both returning an impressive 9.9%.
Smaller funds facing challenges accessing expertise.
Some entities face challenges accessing expertise in fixed income. Often smaller funds do not have the scale required to warrant an individual mandate by larger outsourced asset managers who typically offer a managed trust. This solution does not appeal to all and we are seeing a growing number of smaller entities taking advantage of our Managed Income Portfolio Service which allows for customisation for amounts greater than $5 million. Such utilisation of specialist managers is serving smaller funds well as they are able to access expertise beyond their own internal capabilities.
It would seem therefore that the writing is on the wall for the next couple of years at least and sustainable growth will be front of mind. Portfolio managers have a real challenge on their hands as individuals, businesses and governments learn to live with COVID-19. In an environment where much of the future feels uncertain, one thing we can expect is that the next two years will test the mettle of all investors, be that the largest super funds or the smallest SMSFs.